中文    English

Journal of library and information science in agriculture ›› 2025, Vol. 37 ›› Issue (3): 53-65.doi: 10.13998/j.cnki.issn1002-1248.25-0220

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Comparative Research on International Online Open Digital Literacy Assessment Tools

WANG Xiaokun   

  1. Shanxi Medical University Library, Jinzhong 030600
  • Received:2025-01-23 Online:2025-03-05 Published:2025-06-10

Abstract:

[Purpose/Significance] In the digital age, digital literacy is a core competency that individuals need to cope with challenges and achieve comprehensive development. A digital literacy assessment is the starting point for the improvement of citizens' digital literacy. It enables individuals to understand their level of digital literacy and provides organizations with the information they need to develop digital literacy construction policies and conduct education and training programs. At present, no literature is available on the comparative study of open digital literacy assessment tools. [Method/Process] First, we used keywords to retrieve information related to digital literacy assessment tools, and then we browsed and filtered the search results. Next, we read the information on the official website of the assessment tools and tried the tools, and finally we selected the tools. The article introduces eight online, open digital literacy assessment tools: MyDigiSkills tool, Digital Skills Accelerator tool, Ikanos test for citizens, Test your digital skills tool, The Digital Competence Wheel tool, Pix test, Digital Citizenship test, and Northstar Digital Literacy Assessment test. We carried out comparative research on these assessment tools from the following perspectives: development institution, assessment object, assessment framework, test design and assessment result. [Results/Conclusions] The article makes some suggestions for China regarding the formulation of national digital literacy frameworks, the development of online open digital literacy assessment tools, and the implementation of digital literacy education. The Party and State institutions should formulate the frameworks, along with the universities, industry associations and other institutions, as well as researchers in relevant fields. The framework should include the following aspects: the capability system, capability level, and capability description or examples. Organizations can actively develop digital literacy assessment tools for different groups based on the frameworks, adapting them as needed. One type of question can be used by itself or in combination with other types. The assessment tools should display the user's overall digital literacy level and the results of each ability assessment. This allows the user to understand their own digital literacy level and identify areas for improvement. The assessment results can be differentiated, and users can select their level or score form. Training and educational institutions should consider offering training courses related to various abilities. The courses should vary in difficulty to meet the needs of different groups and individuals.

Key words: digital literacy, digital competence, assessment tool, comparative research

CLC Number: 

  • G202

Table 1

The defining institutions and meanings of concepts of digital competence, digital intelligence and digital literacy"

概念名称定义机构概念涵义
数字能力欧盟在学习、工作和社会参与中自信地、批判地和负责地使用数字技术。它包括信息和数据素养、交流与合作、媒介素养、数字内容创作(包括编程)、安全(包括数字幸福和与网络安全相关的能力)、知识产权相关问题、问题解决和批判性思维
数字智商DQ研究所一组全面的技术、认知、元认知和社会情感能力。这些能力以普遍的道德价值观为基础,使个人能够面对数字生活的挑战并利用机会
数字素养素养明尼苏达为了在虚拟空间中有效沟通并完成社交和与工作相关的任务而访问和操作联网设备、成功使用常用软件、导航和利用在线资源所需的能力和知识

Table 2

A comparison of eight online open digital literacy assessment tools"

序号工具名称开发机构评估对象评估框架试题设计评估结果
1MyDigiSkills工具ALL DIGITAL协会公民DigComp框架自评试题(李克特量表)显示每个能力领域和每项能力的级别
2Digital Skills Accelerator工具波兰西波美拉尼亚技术大学、西班牙阿尔卡拉大学、英国Canice咨询公司、爱尔兰Momentum组织、欧洲大学终身学习协会高等教育机构的学生DigComp框架自评试题(李克特量表)

显示每个能力领域的得分

根据得分情况给用户建议需要优先关注的模块,并有相应的学习资源

3公民版Ikanos测试西班牙巴斯克自治区政府经济发展与基础设施部公民DigComp框架自评试题(李克特量表、二分量表、选择题)显示整体能力、每个能力领域及每项具体能力的级别
4Test your digital skills工具欧盟委员会公民(重点是就业情境下的人们)DigComp框架

自评试题(李克特量表)

知识型试题(选择题、判断题)

显示整体能力和每个能力领域的级别,以及每个能力领域的水平概况和能力示例

还提供了每个能力领域的相关培训课程、教育项目等资源的链接

5The Digital Competence Wheel工具丹麦Center for Digital Dannelse成年公民对DigComp框架进行改编自评试题(李克特量表)

显示整体能力、每个能力领域及每项具体能力的得分和级别

此外,对于每项具体能力,列举了能力的示例,说明了拥有能力的益处,提出了加强能力的练习建议

6Pix测试

设计团队(2016—2017年)

Pix组织(2017年至今)

公民(重点是各阶段的学生)数字能力参考框架

知识型试题(选择题、问答题等)

操作型试题(问答题、交互模拟题等)

完成一轮测试后,系统显示每道题的答题结果、正确答案、解析指导(部分答错题有)、与题目内容相关的延伸教程链接(部分题有)

完成一个测评模块后,系统显示该项具体能力的pix总分和级别,并且提供了提高这项能力的延伸教程链接

显示用户的Pix测试总分

7Digital Citizenship测试DQ研究所公民(重点是儿童和青少年)DQ框架数字公民级别的8个能力域

自评试题(李克特量表、选择题)

知识型试题(选择题)

显示用户的测试总分和数字公民类型
8Northstar Digital Literacy Assessment测试

Tom Cytron-Hysom、Jen Vanek、Jennifer Asp、Michael Graif组成的设计团队(2011—2012年)

素养明尼苏达(2012年至今)

公民(主要面向成年人)Northstar标准

知识型试题(选择题、判断题、配对题、交互模拟题)

操作型试题(交互模拟题)

完成一个测试模块后,显示该项技能的得分,列出用户已掌握的能力和需要提高的能力

Table 3

Assessment frameworks of assessment tools"

工具名称评估框架
MyDigiSkills工具

DigComp框架的5个能力领域,21项具体能力:

1.信息和数据素养(1.1浏览、搜索与筛选数据、信息和数字内容;1.2评估数据、信息和数字内容;1.3管理数据、信息和数字内容)

2.交流与合作(2.1通过数字技术交流;2.2通过数字技术分享;2.3通过数字技术使用公民身份;2.4通过数字技术合作;2.5网络礼仪;2.6管理数字身份)

3.数字内容创作(3.1创作数字内容;3.2整合与再加工数字内容;3.3版权和许可;3.4编程)

4.安全(4.1保护设备;4.2保护个人数据和隐私;4.3保护健康和幸福;4.4保护环境)

5.问题解决(5.1解决技术问题;5.2识别需求和技术对策;5.3创新地使用数字技术;5.4识别数字能力差距)

Digital Skills Accelerator工具
公民版Ikanos测试
Test Your Digital Skills工具DigComp框架的5个能力领域
Pix测试

数字能力参考框架,包括5个能力领域,16项具体能力:

1.信息和数据(1.1完成搜索和信息智力;1.2数据管理;1.3数据处理)

2.交流与合作(2.1交流;2.2分享和传送;2.3合作;2.4加入数字世界)

3.内容创作(3.1创作文本文档;3.2创作多媒体文档;3.3适应各种用途的文档;3.4编程)

4.保护与安全(4.1使数字环境安全;4.2保护个人数据和隐私;4.3保护健康、幸福和环境)

5.数字环境(5.1解决技术问题;5.2建设数字环境)

The Digital Competence Wheel工具

框架包括4个能力领域,16项具体能力:

1.信息(1.1存储;1.2搜索;1.3批判性评价;1.4自助服务)

2.交流(2.1积极参与;2.2合作;2.3社交意识;2.4媒介选择)

3.生产(3.1生产和分享;3.2数字探索;3.3自动化;3.4配置)

4.安全(4.1法律;4.2身份管理;4.3数据保护;4.4健康)

Digital Citizenship测试DQ框架数字公民级别的8个能力域:1.数字公民身份;2.技术的均衡使用;3.行为网络风险管理;4.个人网络安全管理;5.数字共情;6.数字足迹管理;7.媒介和信息素养;8.隐私管理
Northstar Digital Literacy Assessment测试

Northstar标准的3个领域,17项数字技能:

1.基本的计算机技能(1.1手机键盘基础及登录;1.2计算机技能基础;1.3网络基础;1.4使用Email;1.5Windows10操作系统;1.6Windows11操作系统;1.7Mac操作系统)

2.基本的软件技能(2.1Word软件;2.2Excel软件;2.3PowerPoint软件;2.4Google Docs软件)

3.在日常生活中使用技术(3.1社交媒体;3.2信息素养;3.3职业搜索技能;3.4支持K-12远程学习;3.5远程医疗预约;3.6个人数字足迹)

1 BARTOLOMÉ J, GARAIZAR P. Design and validation of a novel tool to assess citizens' netiquette and information and data literacy using interactive simulations[J]. Sustainability, 2022, 14(6): 3392.
2 RÓŻEWSKI P, KIERUZEL M, LIPCZYŃSKI T, et al. Concept of expert system for creation of personalized, digital skills learning pathway[J]. Procedia computer science, 2019, 159: 2304-2312.
3 王碧. 法国Pix数字能力认证系统的实践及启示[J]. 晋图学刊, 2021(5): 35-40, 67.
WANG B. Practice and enlightenment of French pix digital competence certification system[J]. Shanxi library journal, 2021(5): 35-40, 67.
4 MATTAR J, RAMOS D K, LUCAS M R. DigComp-based digital competence assessment tools: Literature review and instrument analysis[J]. Education and information technologies, 2022, 27(8): 10843-10867.
5 高欣峰, 於冰双. 国际数字素养评价与认证分析: 以欧洲4个典型工具为例[J]. 成人教育, 2022, 42(10): 86-93.
GAO X F, YU B S. Analysis on international digital literacy assessment and certification: Take four typical European tools as examples[J]. Adult education, 2022, 42(10): 86-93.
6 CLIFFORD I, KLUZER S, TROIA S, et al. DigCompSAT: A self-reflection tool for the European digital competence framework for citizens[R/OL]. [2024-12-02]. .
7 KLUZER S, CENTENO C, O´KEEFFE W. DigComp at work - The EU's digital competence framework in action on the labour market: A selection of case studies[R/OL]. [2024-12-02]. .
8 Commission European. Launch of new European online self-assessment tool for digital skills[EB/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
9 Ministère de l'Éducation nationale. Première étape franchie pour le nouveau service public en ligne D'évaluation et de certification des compétences numériques (Pix)[EB/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
10 Ministère de I'Éducation nationale. Cadre de référence des compétences numériques[EB/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
11 PARK Y. DQ global standards report 2019: Common framework for digital literacy, skills and readiness[R/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
12 DQ Institute. World's first global standard for digital literacy, skills and readiness launched by the coalition for digital intelligence[EB/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
13 DQ Institute. Global launch of the digital citizenship test on the safer internet day[EB/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
14 Minnesota Literacy. About northstar[EB/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
15 CYTRON-HYSOM T, HADLEY K, VANEK J, et al. Assessing and building digital literacy skills for low-skilled adults: A practical approach[EB/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
16 VUORIKARI R, KLUZER S, PUNIE Y. DigComp 2.2: The digital competence framework for citizens - With new examples of knowledge, skills and attitudes[R/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
17 DQ Institute. Digital intelligence[EB/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
18 Minnesota Literacy. Definitions and facts[EB/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
19 Commission European. Test your digital skills and thrive in the digital world[EB/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
20 PAULE L G. Pix[EB/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
21 DQ Institute. Digital citizenship test: Cyber-risk and digital skills assessment launch[EB/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
22 SKOV A. What is digital competence[EB/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
23 KLUZER S, PRIEGO L P. DigComp into action: Get inspired, make it happen - A user guide to the European digital competence framework[R/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
24 CENTENO C. DigComp at work: Implementation guide[R/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
25 中央网络安全和信息化委员会.提升全民数字素养与技能行动纲要[EB/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
26 教育部. 教师数字素养[EB/OL]. [2024-12-03]. .
27 全民数字素养与技能发展水平调查研究组. 全民数字素养与技能发展水平调查报告(2024)[R/OL] [2024-12-04]. .
[1] SUN Zhimei, LIU Yan, LIU Wenyun, LI Ruiqin. Perception and Utilization of Digital Literacy Knowledge by University Library Users from Representational Pers Perspective [J]. Journal of library and information science in agriculture, 2025, 37(2): 23-36.
[2] LUO Guofeng, YI Tong, YAN Zhouzhou. Critical Information Literacy Education in University Libraries from the Perspective of AIGC Application [J]. Journal of library and information science in agriculture, 2025, 37(1): 47-58.
[3] Xuemei LUO, Yuzhe LIN. Graduate Student Digital Literacy Promotion Pathway Driven by AIGC [J]. Journal of library and information science in agriculture, 2024, 36(9): 70-77.
[4] Baiyang LI, Rong SUN. Construction of an AI Literacy General Education Curriculum Based on "Knowledge-Skills" Navigation [J]. Journal of library and information science in agriculture, 2024, 36(8): 34-42.
[5] Chen MA, Jin LI, Zexin LI, Beibei FAN, Xian FENG. Evaluation and Influencing Factors of Farmers' Digital Literacy Levels in the Context of the Digital Countryside [J]. Journal of library and information science in agriculture, 2024, 36(7): 19-33.
[6] WANG Xiaoyu, ZHANG Suluo. Farmers' Digital Literacy under the Background of Digital Rural Construction: Concept and Framework Construction [J]. Journal of library and information science in agriculture, 2024, 36(5): 52-64.
[7] YANG Xing. Practice and Enlightenment of Developing Librarians' Digital Scholarship Service Skills at the University of Florida Library [J]. Journal of library and information science in agriculture, 2024, 36(5): 93-101.
[8] YI Tong, LUO Guofeng. Improving Digital Literacy of University Librarians Using Educational Technology [J]. Journal of library and information science in agriculture, 2024, 36(2): 61-70.
[9] WANG Weizheng, QIAO Hong, LI Xiaojun, WANG Jingjing. User Willingness to Use Generative Artificial Intelligence Based on AIDUA Framework [J]. Journal of library and information science in agriculture, 2024, 36(2): 36-50.
[10] Xiaoyu WANG, Shuo LI, Suluo ZHANG. Constructing and Researching the Collaborative Cultivation Model of Farmers' Digital Literacy from the Perspective of Activity Theory [J]. Journal of library and information science in agriculture, 2024, 36(10): 63-75.
[11] CUI Kai. Analysis of Farmers' Information Acquisition Behavior for Digital Inclusion: Group Focus and Practical Concerns [J]. Journal of library and information science in agriculture, 2024, 36(1): 33-45.
[12] XIAO Keyi, LI Yunfan. Present Situation and Enlightenment of Chinese University Libraries' Participation in Digital Humanistic Educational Service from the Perspective of Supply and Demand Matching [J]. Journal of library and information science in agriculture, 2023, 35(5): 37-50.
[13] HUI Xiaomeng, CHEN Yuqing, HUI Lianghong. Modeling the Relationship Between Digital Nativity and Digital Citizenship: Based on the Analysis of SEM and fsQCA [J]. Journal of library and information science in agriculture, 2023, 35(3): 37-51.
[14] ZHENG Rui, DENG Hongzhang. Construction and Demonstration of University Students' Innovation and Entrepreneurship Ability under the Background of "the Belt and Road Initiative": Taking Some Universities in Shaanxi Province as Examples [J]. Journal of library and information science in agriculture, 2022, 34(3): 92-107.
[15] XIAO Peng, ZHAO Qingxiang. The Road to Digital Talent Power: Action Plan for Enhancing Digital Literacy and Skills of the People and College Students' Digital Literacy Education Strategy [J]. Journal of library and information science in agriculture, 2021, 33(12): 6-15.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited

  Shared   
  Discussed   
No Suggested Reading articles found!