中文    English

Journal of Library and Information Science in Agriculture ›› 2021, Vol. 33 ›› Issue (7): 46-53.doi: 10.13998/j.cnki.issn1002-1248.20-0968

• Research paper • Previous Articles     Next Articles

Academic Impact of Retracted Dissertations and Theses

LI Xiaohui, WANG Jue, LANG Linfang   

  1. Harbin Normal University Library, Harbin 150025
  • Received:2020-10-28 Online:2021-07-05 Published:2021-07-28

PDF (PC)

213

Abstract: [Purpose/Significance] This study examined the distribution of retracted dissertations and theses in order to explore their negative effects. The purpose is to provide recommendations and strategies for management departments to formulate policies to reduce academic misconduct. [Method/Process] We obtained cases of revoked academic degree through media news, and retrieved various databases and online reading sharing platforms to find the residual situation of the papers. We also analyzed the papers' academic impact by bibliometrics and altmetrics measurement. [Results/Conclusions] The results show that 75% retracted dissertations and theses were still in databases and online reading and sharing platforms, and 36% of them were retracted. Bibliometrics analysis found that 58% retracted papers were cited, and one-third of which occurred after the retraction. Altmetrics analysis found that 84% papers were uploaded, collected, shared, commented, and reposted. And 24% of them were uploaded after the retraction. Finally, we put forward the governance strategies from the perspectives of research integrity education and academic misconduct punishment.

Key words: retracted dissertations and theses, Academic misconduct, research integrity, academic impact, Altmetrics

CLC Number: 

  • G237.5
[1] 杨珠. 学术不端论文未被撤销现象及其治理——基于董鹏学术不端事件的个案分析[J]. 中国科技期刊研究, 2018, 29(7): 691-697.
YANG Z.Phenomenon on unretracted papers of academic misconduct and the corresponding treatment: Based on Dong Peng's academic misconduct[J]. Chinese journal of scientific and technical periodicals, 2018, 29(7):691-697.
[2] 武夷山. 论文撤销之后“谬种”仍会流传[N]. 科学时报, 2011-05-16(A03).
WU Y S. "Fallacy" will still circulate after paper were retracted[N]. China science daily, 2011-05-16(A03).
[3] ISABEL C V, ALBERTO R R.Misconduct as the main cause for retraction. A descriptive study of retracted publications and their authors[J]. Gaceta sanitaria, 2019, 33(4): 1584-1588.
[4] 陈小清, 邢美园. PubMed数据库撤销论文文献计量分析[J]. 中国科技期刊研究, 2016, 27(4): 352-358.
CHEN X Q, XING M Y.Bibliometric analysis of retracted articles in PubMed[J]. Chinese journal of scientific and technical periodicals, 2016, 27(4): 352-358.
[5] 付中静. PubMed数据库中我国论文撤销原因及学术影响力分析[J]. 中国科技期刊研究, 2017, 28(4): 293-299.
FU Z J.An empirical study on reasons of the Chinese retracted articles in PubMed database and its academic influence[J]. Chinese journal of scientific and technical periodicals, 2017, 28(4): 293-299.
[6] JAIME A T D S, JUDIT D. Highly cited retracted papers[J]. Scien-tometrics, 2017, 110(3): 1653-1661.
[7] JUDIT B-I, GALI H.Post retraction citations in context: a case study[J]. Scientometrics, 2017, 113(1): 547-565.
[8] 杨奕虹, 杨贺, 万小影, 等. 利用高被引与零被引数据剖析中国博士学位论文学术影响力[J]. 情报杂志, 2015, 34(7): 22-28.
YANG Y H, YANG H, WAN X Y, et al.Analyzing academic impact of Chinese doctoral dissertations based on high-cited and non-cited articles[J]. Journal of intelligence, 2015, 34(7): 22-28.
[9] MITHU A G, SANJAY K S.Citation analysis of doctoral theses of physics: a bibliometrics study[J]. Library philosophy and practice, 2019.
[10] LORETA T, VAIDAS J.Incongruences of ethical and legal norms in academia: The case on revocation of doctoral degrees[J]. Journal of academic ethics, 2017, 15(1): 73-91.
[11] 高俊杰. 基于学术不端撤销学位的程序制度建构[J]. 中国法学, 2019(5): 47-63.
GAO J J.Procedural system construction for revoking degree based on academic misconduct[J]. China legal science, 2019(5): 47-63.
[12] 王茜, 窦天芳, 胡洪营, 等. 国内外学位论文再出版的政策研究及启示[J]. 大学图书馆学报, 2020, 38(2): 56-62.
WANG Q, DOU T F, HU H Y, et al.Policy research and enlightenment on republication of dissertation at home and abroad[J]. Journal of academic libraries, 2020, 38(2): 56-62.
[13] PRIEM J, TARABORELLI D, GROTH P, et al. Altmetrics: Amanifesto, 26 October 2010[EB/OL]. [2020-02-15]. http://altmetrics.org/manifesto.
[14] WOUTERS P, COSTAS R.Users, narcissism and control-tracking the impact of scholarly publications in the 21st century[M]. SURF foundation, 2012.
[15] 王艳波, 汪雷, 吴小兰. 基Altmetrics与文献计量指标的国内学术论文影响力评价研究[J/OL]. 情报理论与实践: 1-10[2020-03-07].http://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/11.1762.G3.20191219.0845.002.html.
WANG Y B, WANG L, WU X L. Research on the Impact evaluation of domestic academic papers based on altermetrics and traditional bibliometric indicators[J/OL]. Information studies: theory & applica-tion: 1-10[2020-03-07]. http://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/11.1762.G3.20191219.0845.002.html.
[16] 姚长青, 田瑞强, 杨冬雨, 等. 撤销论文及其学术影响研究[J]. 中国科技期刊研究, 2014, 25(5): 595-604.
YAO C Q, TIAN R Q, YANG D Y, et al.Research on retracted ar-ticles and its academic impact[J]. Chinese journal of scientific and technical periodicals, 2014, 25(5): 595-604.
[17] JOS L O.Relationship between altmetric and bibliometric indicators across academic social sites: The case of CSIC's members[J]. Elsevier ltd, 2015, 9(1): 39-49.
[18] ERTL. Plagiarism in doctoral theses as "occupational risk" of government ministers? The debate on good academic practice in German doctoral education in the light of high-profile plagiarism cases[J]. Oxford review of education, 2018, 44(5): 616-632.
[19] BROOKES P S.Internet publicity of data problems in the bio-science literature correlates with enhanced corrective action[J].
Other, 2014, 2.
[1] LAN Xue, HAN Yi. Data Usability of Book Rating Scores on Social Reading Platform from the Perspective of Altmetrics Evaluation: A Case Study of Douban Reading [J]. Journal of Library and Information Science in Agriculture, 2021, 33(11): 74-82.
[2] CHEN Yunwei. Review on Quantitative Methods of Science and Technology Evaluation [J]. Journal of Library and Information Science in Agriculture, 2020, 32(8): 4-11.
[3] ZHOU Jie, LIU Haitao. Application of Blockchain Technology in the Construction of Scientific Research Integrity in Universities [J]. Journal of Library and Information Science in Agriculture, 2020, 32(8): 34-39.
[4] YANG Siluo, YU Yonghao. Comparison of Artificial Intelligence Papers and Books Based on Citation and Altmetric Indicators [J]. Agricultural Library and Information, 2019, 31(5): 5-12.
[5] LIU Chunli, LIU Liping, MA Fengmao. Research Status and Application Challenges of Altmetrics to Evaluate the Social Impact of Scientific Research Output [J]. Agricultural Library and Information, 2019, 31(5): 13-20.
[6] YU Houqiang, YIN Zihan, LI Longfei, CHANG Mengli. Study of Ways of Scientific Usage of Altmetrics Data Based on User Cases [J]. Agricultural Library and Information, 2019, 31(5): 21-27.
[7] YU Yisheng, LIU Xinyan. Research on the Influence Evaluation of Altmetrics Hot Papers from the Perspective of Citation Indicators [J]. Agricultural Library and Information, 2019, 31(5): 28-36.
[8] ZHANG Yao. Research on Altmetric Indicators Evaluation system Model Based on Highly Cited Papers in Chinese Journals [J]. Agricultural Library and Information, 2019, 31(5): 37-42.
[9] HUO Zhenxiang, QU Lichun, LI Xiaoping. Resisting Measures and Thinking to Academic Misconduct from the Perspective of Scientific Journal Editor [J]. , 2018, 30(7): 137-140.
[10] ZHANG Juan. Analysis on the Academic Influence and Development Tendency of Sci-tech Journals of CAAS [J]. , 2018, 30(11): 131-134.
[11] ZHANG Yang, YU Yanhui, HUANG Danqing. Comparison between High Attention Papers and ESI Hot Papers: A Case Study of Clinical Medicine [J]. , 2018, 30(10): 13-22.
[12] YANG Siluo, CHENG Aijuan, YUAN Qingli. Research on Three Dimensional Measuring Method of Papers' Influence Based on Altmetrics [J]. , 2018, 30(10): 5-12.
[13] HOU Zhiai. Research on the User Education and Evaluation of University Libraries in Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei [J]. , 2017, 29(5): 121-124.
[14] DI Yan-hong, MA Xin. Analysis of the First Trial Manuscript from the Academic Misconduct [J]. , 2015, 27(12): 143-145.
[15] LU Hong-zhou. Study on Academic Integrity Guarantee Mechanism and Development of Periodicalls [J]. , 2014, 26(7): 133-136.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited
  Shared   
  Discussed   
No Suggested Reading articles found!
Editorial Board of Journal of Library and Information Science in Agriculture
Tel：(010)82109667　Fax：(010)82109667　E-mail：xuekan＠caas.cn
Powered by Beijing Magtech Co., Ltd.
知识共享许可协议